I know that when there is a paper that contains any name of Allah or Qur’anic verses or anything muqadas in Arabic, you cannot toss it away. Does the same apply to when they’re written in English?

Yes same applies to it in english or any other language

I know that when there is a paper that contains any name of Allah or Qur’anic verses or anything muqadas in Arabic, you cannot toss it away. Does the same apply to when they’re written in English?

If it’s written in English you can recycle it