Maulana Syed Ameer Ali Rizvi
User Pic
Name: Maulana Syed Ameer Ali Rizvi
Age: NIL
Location: Lucknow, India
Expertize: Islamic Philosophy, Mysticism and Theology
Question:Jab namaz e zohar ya asr hoti hai toh 1st or 2nd rakat me imam sahab bismillah bolke khamosh ho jaate hai. Toh mujhe mere aziz ne bataya ki uss dauran subhanallah or alhamdulillah padhte hai or kisi or ne bataya ki uss dauran sureh padhte hai? Aap mera confusion dur kr dijiye.

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: Rule ye hai ki jab aap namaz e jama'at me shirkat karte hain to pahli aur doosri rak'at me Imam e Jama'at jo sure padhte hain wo peeche namaz padhne wale sare momeneen ke liye kafi hote hain aur un par suron ke khud se padhne ka fareeza khatm ho jata hai. Uski jagah aap koi doosra zikr jaise subhan Allah etc repeat kar sakte hain ya phir silent bhi rah sakte hain. Lekin koi Surah na padhen.
Question:Tasbeeh e janabe fatima zehra sa padhte waqt agar 1 ya 2 daane extra padh liye jaise allah ho akbar ko galti se 35 martaba padh liye toh kya tasbeeh ko wapas shuru se padhna padega ya fir continue kr skte hai?

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: Agar tasbeeh-e-Hazrat e Zahra s.a. ka sawab chahte hain to ek baar phir se utni hi tadad me padhen jitni batayi gayi hai. Aur agar aisa nahi karte hain tab bhi mutlaq zikr ka sawab zaroor milega Insha Allah lekin Tasbeeh ka nahi.
Question:I would like to know if one were to commit Zina with 3 women. Does he have to take 300 flogs or 100? And does it purify one from the sin and wrath of Allah


Ayatollah:N/A

Answer: If the person has committed Zina with 3 women differently, he will be punished for each time of his sin that means he will take 300 flogs totally, 100 flogs for each zina. A person just gets rid of the punishment of hellfire if he takes punishment in this world but such a person should always repent of this big sin to seek the contentment of Allah (SWT).
Question:Kisi non muslim ko konsi dalil pesh krni chahiye is muaamele me ke
quran allah ka kalaam hai kisi bashar ka nahi except this dalil that Arabic linguistics because yaha kisi ko Arabic nahi aati.

Koi normal sadharan dalil dijiyega jisse kisi aam aadmi ko samjaya ja sake.

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer:
Agar apko kisi bhi normal book ke author ki ilmi shakhsiyat (personality) ka pata lagana ho ya aap author ko to pahle se jante hon lekin ye yaqeen hasil karna ho ki ye book usi author ki likhi hui hai ya nahi to apko us book ko ek baar padhna zaroor padega aur agar aapko wo zaban nahi aati hai jisme wo book likhi gayi hai to kam se kam uska ek sabse achcha aur authentic translation agar apko mil jaye to use padhkar samajhne ki koshish karenge ki kya ye book usi author ki likhi hui hai ya nahi?

Yahi mamla Quran-e-majeed ka bhi hai ki agar hame kisi ke samne ye prove karna ho ki ye Allah ki kitab hai to ek baar Quran ko Arabic me ya at least apni zaban me uska sabse sahi translation to padhna hi padega. Hamare Nabi s.a. ka mojiza Janabe Musa a.s. ki tarah koi asa ya doosri cheez nahi hai balki Quran ki shakl me ek book hai yani unka mojiza "Ilm" hai.

Ab jo bhi is book ko study karega to ye book aaj tak sabko challenge karti hai ki agar tumhe shak hai ki ye book Allah ki taraf se nazil hui hai ki nahi to iska jawab lakar dikhao ya kam se kam iske ek sure (Chapter) ka jawab lakar dikhao, ya sirf 10 ayaton (Verses) ka jawab lakar dikhao aur agar itna bhi nahi kar sakte to sirf 1 ayat (Verse) ka jawab lakar dikhao. Aur ham agar history uthakar dekhen to kai aise logon ne jawab lane ki koshish bhi ki jinki mother tongue Arabic thi aur wo Arab Literature ke expert bhi the lekin wo nakaam rahe aur aaj bhi kai log aisi koshish karte rahte hain lekin hamesha nakaam hote hain iska matlab taqreeban 1450 saal se Arabic ka koi expert aisa nahi paida hua jo iska aisa jawab likhta ki Quran ki barabari kar sake jis se ye prove hota hai ki Quran Insan ki likhi hui kitab nahi hai balki Allah ki kitab hai jaisa ki khud Quran apne bare me claim karta hai.

Yahan par ye point bhi obvious hai ki aisa nahi hai ki Arab me hamesha se ab tak sab Musalman hi rahe hon ki wo Quran ko pahle se maante rahe hon balki bahut se Non-Muslims bhi guzre hain aur aaj bhi hain sirf itna hi nahi balki Islam ke sakht tareen dushman bhi rahe hain to unhone to zaroor chaha hoga ki Quran ke is challenge ko counter kar den lekin unki nakaami sabit karti hai ki Quran Allah ka kalam hai jaisa ki Quran khud apne bare me bayan kahta hai.
Question:Please explain this hadith. What is Imam trying to say?

"Tribulation has been linked to love of this world." - #Imam_Ali (as)

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: In fact this world always demands efforts to reach a particular goal. A single bite of food doesn't go to the mouth without effort and trouble. Especially the person who loves this world more than hereafter, he has to bear always tribulation because he will never be content therefore tribulation is linked with the love of this world and that is inevitable. This is the meaning I understood but Allah knows better. Please always mention reference of Hadith so we can easily find the original text in Arabic for hadith and check the context to explain in a better way.
Question:Is this Hadith is Authentic?

If yes, than please send me reference or jo uska book me sahi urdu tarjuma hai vo please dijyega.

The Prophet said:

Guarantee six things for me and I’ll guarantee paradise for you:
When you speak, don’t lie
When you’re entrusted, don’t betray
When you promise, keep it
Guard your eyes
Withhold your hands
Protect your chastity


Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: This hadith is mentioned in a book named "Nahjul Fasahat" which consists of short sayings of Holy Prophet (PBUH).
The Arabic text of hadith is as following:
اِضمَنوا لى سِتّا مِن اَنفُسِكُم اَضمَن لَكُمُ الجَنَّةَ اُصدُقُوا اِذا حَدَّثتُم و َأوفُوا اِذا وَعَدتُم و َاَدُّوا اِذا ائتُمِنتُم و َاحفَظوا فُروجَكُم و َغُضّوا اَبصارَكُم وَ كُفّوا اَيديَكُم؛


«نهج الفصاحه ص216 ، ح 321»

https://books.shiatiger.com/2016/01/nahj-ul-fasaha.html?m=1
Urd book link
Question:Is there anything that I can do to protect my family. My 2020 started with my beloved aunt’s passing, news of three close friends in the hospital, and financially we are struggling.

Ayatollah:N/A

Answer: The best thing which is recommended by traditions of masoomeen a.s. is to give sadaqa and do isteghfaar as much as possible.

For resolution of financial problems there are a lot of supplications and Ama'al recommended by masoomeen and our Ulama and some of them are experienced by Ulama and a large number of momeneen. Like you can rectite this zikr after fajr 100 times "Ya Wahhabu" and you should recite 27 times verse no. 58 of Surah Zariyat إِنَّ اللَّـهَ هُوَ الرَّزَّاقُ ذُو الْقُوَّةِ الْمَتِينُ after Fajr prayer as well.
Question:Mere fiance PRO(public relations officer) ka kaam karte hai yani students ku college mey admissions karwana. In admissions ke badle college wale kuch amount dete hai. Kya is tarah ka earning sahi hai. Kindly waze kijiye


Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: Apke sawal ke mutabiq ye samajh me aa raha hai ki ye ek tarah ki brokery hai jisme college admission ke badle unhe kuch comission deta hai to ise lene me zaheran koi harj nahi hai.
Question:I have just recently got married and day after our nikah I asked for divorce. Me and my husband started fighting everyday. We asked our local sheikh that to look what's happening between us and they said that is sihr between us. Someone has buried something in graveyard to seperate us. Now my husband doesn't recognize me or consider me his wife. Can you help me in this issue?


Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer:
First of all, I ask you that how are you so much sure about 'Sehr' or the Shaikh who told you about it? `it may have another cause, maybe a misunderstanding or anything else. The first thing is that you should talk with your husband and try to find out the real cause and issue. You may take help of your elders in this regard.

But if all the efforts become unsuccessful and he is not ready to change his behavior then you can ask him to give you divorce but this is the last step and as you know better that divorce is the most unliked halaal act near Almighty Allah. So please avoid it as far as possible.

Although if there is no option except divorce then ask him for divorce. If he does not agree for simple divorce, ask him for a special type of divorce which is called in Islamic Term 'Khula.' In this type of talaq, when a woman doesn't like to continue her marital relationship with a man but the man wants to continue the relations, she offers him some amount to give divorce. The detailed Ahkam of Talaq-e-Khula are mentioned in Risala-e-Tauzeehul Masael.

After all if he is not agree at any condition then contact to you Marja or his representative in your area because they only have power to give onesided divorce from your side.

Kindly keep in your mind my Sister that this way is not recommended in Islam as far as other ways may be sought and applied and don't believe easily on these type of asuumptions that someone has done sehr against you. Even though as a precaution you should write this dua on a paper and always keep it with you. It's recommend by Hazrat Ali a.s. and mentioned in the famous book of dua and Amaal 'Mafateehul Jinan' of Shaikh Abbas Qummi.
بِسمِ الله وَ بِالله، بِسمِ الله وَ ما شاءَالله، بِسم الله لاحَولَ ولاقُوّه الا بالله، قالَ موسی ما جِئتُم بِه السِّحرُ اِنَّ اللهَ سَیُبطِلُهُ اِنَّ اللهَ لا یُصلِحُ عَملَ المُفسِدینَ، فَوَقَعَ الحَقُّ و بَطَلَ ما کانُوا یَعمَلونَ فَغُلِبوا هُنالِکَ وَانقَلَبُوا صاغِرینَ
Don't believe on just imaginations and illusions and don't be skeptic or obsessional untill you find a solid proof of sehr.
Question:My nani’s family is ismaeli. We avoid to eat their food
But sometimes we failed and they forced us to eat what my anty cooked

She believes on Allah swt and Rassoul e Khuda and Imam Ali (as).
Sometimes she do namaz and fast. Is it okay to eat her food when we have no choice? She is considered as muslim right?

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: They are considered Muslims except in the case if they show openly their enmity for any one of the 14 infallibles so you can eat at their home freely until they are proved Nasibi (the open enemy of Ahlul-bayt a.s.)
Total 45 Questions 1 2 3 4 5