Sheikh Mohammed Mehdi
User Pic
Name: Sheikh Mohammed Mehdi
Age: NIL
Location: Sydney
Expertize: Beliefs (Aqeeda), Comparative religion and Qur’an.
Question:Wanted to ask how to treat dhan in Salah. Let’s say you are praying and get doubt in sajdah if it’s the first one or 2nd one. Your mind and the way you pray tells you it’s 2nd should you follow it ? It’s like over 50% probability


Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: If you are still in a seated position and are in doubt, then you must prostrate again.
Question:My friend did mutah with a women without she getting permission from her wali so i told them to follow sayid sadiq al ruhani. Does the woman now need any permission from her wali or is their marrige valid? They both followed Sayid Sadiq Ruhani after they did the sigra.


Ayatollah:Sadeq Rouhani

Answer: They can’t just choose to follow a marja to make things valid. He shouldn’t have done muta with a virgin.
There was a similar scenario asked to Sayed Sadeq Rouhani.

ستفتاء:
السلام عليكم ، انا من مقلدي السيد السيستاني ،
هل يجوز لي الزواج المؤقت من امرأة باكرة بدون اذن وليها وذلك لأن اخد الاذن يسبب الحرج ؟ وهل استطيع الرجوع الى السيد صادق الروحاني في هذه المسألة واتزوج المرأة زواج منقطع بدون اذن وليها ؟
جواب:
باسمه جلت اسماؤه
لا بد للمكلف من العمل على طبق فتوى مرجع تقليده إن كان قد أحرز دليلا شرعيا على تقليده، ولا يجوز له الرجوع الى غيره في أية مسألة الا اذا كان رأيه فيه على نحو الاحتياط، فيجوز الرجوع الى من يعتقد المكلف انه الاعلم بعده.

He has responded that this isn’t permissible in the manner that you have asked.
So your friend should abstain from this woman and seek permission from her wali if intends on continuing the relationship.
Question:May I take house loan from bank if suppose, I want to buy a house, which has value  100000 EUR. Bank will be pay all money directly to the house owner. After it, as per mutual commitment, I will pay 120000EUR via installment (667 EUR per month in 15 years) to the same Bank.
Pls advise me is that permissable or not according to Quran o Hadees's references?

Ayatollah:N/A

Answer: It is forbidden to take it with the intention of loan with the condition of paying interest. However, it is permissible to take the money from the bank that is financed by non-Muslim government or private funds. The knowledge that the bank will sooner or later force him to pay the capital as well as the interest does not affect [the lawfulness of] his taking the money.
Question:I had been feeling restless, anxious with constant worry and thoughts. I cannot find happiness or satisfaction. I had taken professional help and I am on medication from three years but there is no cure nor do I feel better. I am always concerned about my health, my future and my past sins. I am not offering Namaz and I do not know why is this happening, I need your help.Please suggest a course so that I resolve the issues and feel happy without being worried.

Ayatollah:N/A

Answer: Firstly, may Allah alleviate your pain. You need to understand that happiness and satisfaction is only a result of being content.
Medicine is only a placebo when it comes to these issues.

Despair is the bane of hope, it is the opposite of hope, it is a distinctive feature of the unbeliever.
Allah says in his Holy Quran

إِنَّهُ لاَ يَيْأَسُ مِن رَّوْحِ اللّهِ إِلاَّ الْقَوْمُ الْكَافِرُونَ
[12:87] surely none despairs of Allah's mercy except the unbelieving people.

There is a deep rooted connection between despair and disbelief. Because the disbeliever’s thoughts and beliefs are all based upon cause and effect; They don’t believe in الإرادة الإلاهية (Gods will or wish).

The physical laws pertain to us, he transcends all of this.

The nature of this life is to have problems and issues. We always hear people complain about their issues, but we are here to be tried and not to live in comfort, comfort was only created for the hereafter.

An individual upon encountering a problem automatically feels it is the end of the road.

إِن مَّسَّهُ الشَّرُّ فَيَئُوسٌ قَنُوطٌ
[41:49] if evil touches him, he is hopeless and despairing.

The believer in the worst situations should fill their heart with hope.

Things always change, don’t forget that God fixes things.

Remember when you were young and how you never worried about anything because your parents had all bases covered. Why do we lose this as we grow? When Allah is far greater than our parents at looking after our future and resolving our issues.

You need to remember
1. We were created to be tried
2. This world is transient
3. Allah rewards us based on our resolve in these situations.
4. Only the first hundred years are difficult for the believer. After that is eternal enjoyment.
Question:Can we purchase grocery and other non alcoholic things from a supermarket (like Woolworths, Coles, Aldi in Australia) which also sells liquor and alcoholic beverages in the same premise?

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: Yes, their primary product is not alcohol, you haven’t walked into a bar to purchase groceries.
Question:1) Will swimming pool water be considered as kur water?

2) Also will the water become Narjis if other non-believers also swim in it?

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: 1) If it is a pool that has more than 384 litres, that is in all three dimensions greater than 36 hand spans, then yes

2) If it is greater than a Kurr, as long as the smell, colour or taste of the water doesn’t change it remains pure.
Question:In Quran its clearly mentioned that dont get divided into sects hold on to the rope of Allah but still why there are so many sects in Muslims?
And if Allah wanted us to be one then why Allah did not guided Muslims to be one?


Ayatollah:N/A

Answer: If Allah makes every person follow one faith, then there is no trial and we don’t have free will. Your duty is to follow what Allah commanded you to follow. All main Sunni texts state that one should follow Quran and Ahlul Bayt, then why do they follow Abu Bakr and Umar? This is the question that should be asked.
Question:Is it permissible to use a cellphone during a mustahab salat in order to read it the right way if we have not memorized the instructions? Like salat-e-witr for example. Also, is it permissible to use a cellphone to read a specific dua during qunoot?


Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: This is no different to holding a book. You are reading the same thing, only the medium is different. So it’s ok for what you have asked about.
Question:In your opinion do orchestras which usually play classical music symphonies count as amusement gatherings? Or are amusement gatherings generally more up beat party type environments?


Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: This is not based on my opinion, this is based on what is known, are symphony orchestras considered to be music played in places of entertainment by the general public? This is a question that you personally must deduce, my response is valid for me only and not for you. So I cannot respond to this unfortunately.
Question:Islam strictly forbids seeing porn, naked images and namahrams. If we follow this totally and stay away from it, our minds starts to forget all that things but science says we should maintain our sex life other wise man will losse his sex power. As for the youth, what can they do in this case because married couple has no problem in this issue but unmarried, what they have to do if they stay away from porn or naked images? They’ll lose their sex power but if they stay connected to it then it is haram to watch. What Islam suggest about this and what if marrying early is not possible to solve the problem

Ayatollah:Sistani

Answer: Science says? Who is science? You need to provide evidence and research to make such a claim. Because this claim is false. On the contrary one must preoccupy themselves with other things to remove these thoughts. They must endeavour to get married as soon as possible to unleash their desires.
It is forbidden to view pornography, you won’t lose your libido don’t worry, it will be put hold.
How do we maintain a good sex life? Through marriage, permanent or temporary.
Total 107 Questions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11